StateRepression.com
  • Home
  • Welcome
  • What is State Repression?
  • Repression Data
  • US repression - the movie?!
  • Featured data
  • Featured Reading
  • INcomplete Must-read list
  • Featured Repression Scholar
  • Repression Resources
  • (Car)Toons 'o Repression
  • Caveat Civis - Citizen Beware

Divided we stand

1/1/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
It appears as if the study of state repression is significantly divided between IR and comparative.  The former highlights factors relevant to IR: treaties, trade, international law and so on.  The former highlights factors that are relevant to comparative politics: domestic conflict, democracy, economic development and the like.  To each is own.  

The division would be acceptable but only if the insights provided by the other were included.  For example, if research identifies that a specific functional form of a relationship is an "s" shape, then unless someone comes along to show that the relationships is actually a z shape, then all models should use the s.  But people keep using a v shape!  Poor specification does have implications, no?

Of course, if scholars interested in only one type of explanation (i.e., IR or comparative) do not use the best models, then 1) their work is wrong and/or 2) the peer review system is dysfunctional for allowing such work to be published.  The problem seems to be that the two different areas largely publish in different journals and when they do publish in the same journals editors tend to select reviewers that are familiar with one strand or the other.  To each their own.

The end result: we end up with a poor understanding of the topic.  

Solution: ask what the best model is, what is the state of the art operationalization for a specific variable and then use it.  

Can't we all just google it?  Googletruth - coming soon...

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Christian Davenport's Caveat Civis - Citizen Beware

    Given the elusive nature of state repression, it is crucial to be constantly aware of information as it becomes available.  This is not always easy to do and with the different tactics, perpetrators, locations and victims of domestic spying, torture, arrest, detention, disappearances and mass killing, it is necessary to keep one's eyes open, along with one's mind - Citizen's Beware.  The data is out there.  We just need to find it and figure out what it means.

    Archives

    February 2017
    January 2017
    May 2016
    November 2015
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    Comparative Politics
    Conflict Studies
    Conflict Studies
    Covert Action
    Crowd Control
    Data
    Democratic Peace
    Domestic Spying
    Genocide
    Informants
    International Relations
    Language
    Mass Killing
    Misogynists
    Music
    Never Again
    Non-lethal Weaponry
    Northern Ireland
    Obama
    Peace Studies
    Pepper Spray
    Political Violence
    Pop Culture
    Protest Policing
    Research
    Rubber Bullets
    Social Media
    Social Science
    Social Science
    Targeted Assassination
    Technology
    Terror
    Torture
    Weapons

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from dullhunk, rossbreadmore